How and When to Exercise Stock Options

Man standing in front of a discovery
Middle School

How and When to Exercise Stock Options


Let’s talk about a topic that might seem a bit intimidating at first glance, but is actually a fantastic tool for growing your wealth and securing your financial future. We’re talking about stock options, specifically, how to exercise stock options.

Think of stock options like a secret door in a video game. Many players might walk right past it, but those who know about it can unlock a world of treasures. Similarly, understanding stock options can open up a whole new realm of investing opportunities.

Why are we talking about this, you might ask? Well, it’s simple. If you’ve ever been given stock options as part of your compensation package, or if you’re considering a job that offers them, it’s absolutely vital to understand what they are and how to make the most out of them.

Now, before we go deep into the world of stock options, let’s set the scene with some quick and easy definitions. A stock option is a contract that gives you the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell a company’s stock at a specific price, known as the strike price, before a certain date. In simpler words, it’s a bit like knowing a club owner that can sell you VIP tickets to a concert at a certain price. You get the option to buy a ticket before anyone else, and you get it at a set price, no matter how much prices may rise or fall later.

By the end of this article, you’ll have a clear understanding of what it means to exercise stock options, and you’ll be well on your way to making more informed financial decisions. So, let’s open that secret door and explore the world of stock options together.

What are Stock Options?

Stock options, my friend, can be a bit like the special ingredients in your grandmother’s secret sauce recipe. They add that extra flavor to your investment portfolio and can potentially spice up your financial gains. But what exactly are they?

Imagine you’re at a yard sale, and you spot a vintage comic book. The owner offers you a deal. For a small fee now, you can have the option to buy the comic book at today’s price, anytime within the next year. This is essentially how a stock option works. It’s a contract that gives you the right to buy or sell a specific amount of a company’s stock, at a set price, within a certain timeframe.

Now, let’s break it down a bit more:

  • The company’s stock we’re talking about? That’s called the “underlying stock.”
  • The set price? That’s known as the “strike price.”
  • And the specific timeframe? That’s the “expiration date.”

The beauty of stock options is that they give you flexibility. You can choose to exercise the option and buy the stock, or you can let it expire if it’s not in your best interest to make the purchase. It’s a bit like having a reservation at your favorite restaurant. You can choose to go, or if your plans change, you can decide not to show up.

Remember, though, while stock options can offer potential rewards, they’re not without risk. But don’t worry! We’ll dive into how to navigate those risks later in our journey.

Why are Stock Options Important?

If stock options are the secret ingredients in your grandmother’s recipe, understanding why they’re important is a bit like realizing why grandma insists on using those ingredients. It’s all about the flavor they bring to the dish, or in this case, the benefits they can add to your financial life.

First off, stock options can potentially lead to financial gains. If the company’s stock price rises above the strike price, you could buy the stock at the lower strike price and then sell it at the current higher market price. It’s like being able to buy a concert ticket at a discounted rate and then selling it for a profit when the show sells out.

Secondly, stock options can provide you with a level of control over your investment decisions. Because you have the option, but not the obligation to buy or sell the stock, you can make decisions based on what’s best for your financial situation. It’s like having a “skip” button during a game show, you can choose to answer the question or skip it if it’s too hard.

Lastly, they can add diversity to your investment portfolio. Having different types of investments can help spread out potential risk.

However, just like adding too much of grandma’s secret ingredient can overpower the dish, relying too heavily on stock options can introduce additional risk. That’s why it’s crucial to understand them fully and use them wisely. In our next section, we’ll explore how to do just that. So, stick around, we’re just getting to the good part!

How and When to Exercise Stock Options?

Exercising public stock options is like going shopping at your favorite store with a discount coupon. You get to buy something you want at a lower price. Here’s how you can go about it:

First, you’ll need to have a brokerage account. This is like your shopping basket where you’ll place your stocks. If you don’t have one yet, you’ll need to set one up.

Next, you need to buy the option. This is similar to getting your hands on that discount coupon. You pay a small price (the option premium) for the right to buy or sell the stock later at a set price (the strike price).

Now, here’s where it gets exciting. When the market price of the stock is higher than your call option’s strike price (just like when your favorite item is on sale), you can exercise your call option. This is where you use your discount coupon to buy the stock at the lower strike price. This means the option is in-the-money. More on that in our previous article about stock option strike price here.

After you’ve bought the stock, you can either keep it in your portfolio (like adding your new item to your collection) or sell it at the higher market price to make a profit.

Here are the steps in simpler terms:

  1. Open a brokerage account if you don’t already have one.
  2. Buy a call or a put option for the stock you’re interested in. If you’re bullish, buy a call. If you’re bearish, buy a put.
  3. Monitor the market price of the stock.
  4. If the market price goes above (in the case of call options) or below (in the case of put options) your strike price, you may want to exercise your option. There should be a simple way for you to do that in your brokerage account.
  5. If you exercise a call, you will buy the stock at the strike price. If you exercise a put, you will sell the stock at the strike price; if you did not have the stock to sell, this means you will be short-selling.
  6. Decide whether to keep the stock or sell it at the current market price. Or if you short-sold because you exercised a put option, decide whether you want to buy the shares back and make a profit.

Remember, just like with any shopping spree, it’s essential to make sure you’re making wise decisions. Always consider the risks and make sure exercising the option fits into your overall investment strategy.

If you do not wish to own the stock or short-sell the stock, an alternative to exercising a stock option that is in the money is to simply sell your option at a profit. This avoids the need to own shares or short-sell shares when exercising call or put options. It skips the steps of exercising, buying, and selling the stock in order to make a profit.

How to Exercise Stock Options with a Vesting Period?

Let’s consider you work for a company that has given you stock options as part of your compensation package. It’s a bit like your boss handing you a golden ticket to a chocolate factory. This ticket, or in our case, stock options, come with a “vesting period”.

A vesting period is a bit like waiting for a cake to bake. You can’t take it out of the oven too soon, or it won’t be ready. Similarly, you have to wait a certain period before you can “exercise” your stock options. This is usually a way for companies to incentivize employees to stick around and contribute to the company’s growth. The vesting period could be gradual over months and years.

Now, when the vesting period is over, and the stock’s current market price is higher than your strike price, it could be a good time to exercise your stock options. This means you buy the stock at the strike price and can then sell it at the current market price, pocketing the difference.

Here’s how it works in simple steps:

  1. Wait for your stock options to vest.
  2. Monitor the market price of the stock.
  3. If the market price is higher than your strike price, consider exercising your options. If your company uses Carta for granting you options, you’ll find more information on how to exercise your option here. Other services have a similar process.
  4. Buy the stock at the strike price.
  5. Sell the stock at the current market price to make a profit or keep the stock if you think the company will do well in the future.

Keep in mind that this is a simplified view, and various factors could influence your decision, like tax implications and your overall investment strategy.

Remember, like deciding when to eat that ripe piece of fruit, timing is key when exercising stock options.

Key Factors to Consider Before Exercising Stock Options

Before exercising your stock options, you need to consider a few things. It’s a bit like planning a road trip. You wouldn’t just jump in the car and go, right? You’d probably check the weather, plan your route, and maybe even pack some snacks.

Road trip

Here are some key factors you should consider:

  • Company’s performance and prospects: This is like checking the weather for your road trip. You want to know if it’s the right time to go. If the company’s doing well and you believe it’ll continue to do well, it might be a good time to exercise your options.
  • Your personal financial situation: Can you afford to buy the stock at the strike price? It’s like making sure you have enough gas money for your trip. If you can’t afford it, it might not be the right time to exercise your options.
  • Tax implications: Exercising stock options can have tax implications. It’s like considering toll roads on your trip. You need to know how it’ll impact your overall costs. You might want to consult with a tax advisor to understand this better.
  • Your overall investment strategy: How do stock options fit into your overall investment plan? It’s like deciding if this road trip fits into your overall travel plans. If it doesn’t align, it might not be the best choice.

Remember, deciding to exercise stock options shouldn’t be an impulsive decision. It should be a calculated move, just like planning a successful road trip.

Pros and Cons of Exercising Stock Options

Exercising stock options can be a bit like a roller coaster ride. There are some exciting upsides, but there can be some dips as well. Let’s take a look at both sides of the coin.

The Pros:

  • Potential for significant profit: If the market price goes up above your strike price, you can buy the stock at a discount and potentially make a tidy profit. It’s like getting the front seat on the roller coaster – it can be quite a thrilling ride!
  • Control over timing: You decide when to exercise your options (within the validity period, of course). This means you have some control over the timing of your potential profits or losses. It’s like choosing when to ride the roller coaster.
  • Leverage: You can control a large amount of stock for a relatively small cost (the option premium). This means you can potentially make a larger profit (or loss) compared to investing the same amount directly in the stock.

The Cons:

  • Risk of loss: If the market price doesn’t go above your strike price before the option expires, you could lose the money you paid for the option. This is like the dizzy feeling you get after a particularly twisty part of the roller coaster ride.
  • Complexity: Stock options can be complex to understand and manage. It’s not quite as simple as just buying and selling stocks.
  • Tax implications: There can be tax implications when you exercise stock options and when you sell the stocks you acquire. It’s like the unexpected photo they take during the ride – it can catch you off guard if you’re not prepared.

Remember, just like a roller coaster, it’s important to know what you’re getting into before you strap in and start the ride. Make sure you understand the risks and benefits, and consult with a financial advisor if needed.


So, that’s the scoop on exercising stock options. It’s a bit like choosing the perfect ice cream flavor at a gelato shop. It can be really sweet and rewarding, but you also have to be careful not to get a brain freeze. Here’s a quick recap of what we’ve covered:

  • Stock options give you the right to buy or sell a company’s stock at a set price.
  • They can be a great way to potentially make a profit if the company’s stock price goes up or down.
  • But, just like choosing a sorbet over a cream-based flavor, there can be some potential downsides to be aware of too.
  • And remember, just like at a gelato shop, there are plenty of other flavors, or investment options, to consider too.


When it comes to exercising stock options, the key takeaway is that it’s all about making informed decisions. It’s important to understand what stock options are, why they’re important, and how and when to exercise them.

But don’t forget about the other flavors in your investment gelato shop. Each investment option has its own pros and cons, and what works best for you will depend on your personal financial goals and risk tolerance.

And with that, we’ve reached the end of our journey through the world of stock options. Just like finishing a tasty gelato, it might be the end of one treat, but there are always more flavors to try. So, keep exploring, keep learning, and keep making informed decisions about your financial future. Happy investing!